101°F
weather icon Clear

Judge recuses self from crosswalk protest case

Boulder City Municipal Court’s judge has recused himself from the city’s crosswalk protest case because his impartiality has been questioned in district court.

“I did it to avoid the appearance of impropriety,” said Judge Victor Miller.

On Monday, April 9, Miller issued an order of recusal that said attorney Craig Anderson of Marquis Aurbach Coffing, who was retained by the city to represent him in a case regarding a gag order he issued, “apparently gleaned” a statement of facts from a separate pending case in federal court.

Miller said that the rules of judicial conduct require a judge to disqualify him- or herself when the judge’s impartiality might be reasonably questioned.

“Once the attorney filed things I hadn’t approved that seemed to favor one side, that left me without the ability to correct myself in the minds of the people,” he said.

Miller said he did not provide the questionable information to his attorney and did not know it was included in the response to the case filed against him in Nevada’s Eighth District Court until he was provided with a copy of it the morning of April 5 before a hearing about the gag order.

“Therefore, in light of the attorney acting on behalf of the undersigned judge filing a statement of facts relative to this case in another action in district court (even though it was without the judge’s consent or knowledge) this could reasonably lead to the appearance of partiality,” he wrote in the recusal. “As a result, the undersigned judge must recuse himself from further action on this matter.”

The April 5 district court hearing was for a petition for a Writ of Mandamus filed in March by attorney Stephen Stubbs, attorney for Boulder City resident John Hunt, who was arrested on several charges after a crosswalk protest against a police-sanctioned pedestrian enforcement event. Stubbs sought to restore his right to free speech that he said Miller took away from him through the gag order he issued in the city’s case against Hunt.

“Judge Miller did the right thing by recusing himself,” he said in a written statement. “It was disheartening to see Judge Miller and City Attorney Steve Morris working together, with a joint attorney, in their quest to find my client guilty without due process. Judge Miller has shown his true colors: illegal ex-parte communications, secret collusions with City Attorney Steve Morris, his ecclesiastic leader, conflicts of interest, and an unconstitutional gag order. Now, I hope my client gets a fair trial.”

During the hearing and in his reply to Miller’s response filed in the case, Stubbs said that including information from a criminal case that had not yet gone to trial in Miller’s court was wrong.

“Before trial, Judge Miller has prejudged John Hunt and adopted, verbatim, the city of Boulder City’s facts as set out in their motion for summary judgment in the federal civil rights case,” he wrote in his reply.

Stubbs also said that since Miller has the same attorney as the city in Hunt’s federal case against Boulder City, it is “literally impossible” for the city and Miller to have avoided improper communication.

Stubbs said the collusion and one-sided communication was proven by Morris’ statement in support of Miller that was submitted for the district court case.

Hunt’s case will be transferred to a pro tempore judge of the Boulder City Municipal Court, and Miller does not think this will delay the criminal trial scheduled for May 23 and 24.

The gag order issued Feb. 22 was because of a social media post Stubbs made about then-Acting City Attorney Morris, which said he did not care about the First Amendment.

The Judge Susan H. Johnson of the Eighth District Court will write an order in the district case about whether the gag order violated Stubbs’ First Amendment rights.

Contact reporter Celia Shortt Goodyear at cgoodyear@bouldercityreview.com or at 702-586-9401. Follow her on Twitter @csgoodyear.

THE LATEST
It’s official(ish)

It’s all over, at least until November.

Slice of Americana turns 76

Boulder City’s annual July 4 Damboree is almost like a Norman Rockwell painting that has jumped off the canvas and has come to life.

Capturing life through the lens of a camera

If it’s true that a picture is worth a thousand words, it’s safe to say that Bill Bruninga has enough to fill an entire set of encyclopedias.

Boulder City dodges insurance inflation

Insurance is one of those things that are super important but that most people are not going to discuss over a beer like it was a football game. Which is a nice way of saying that the subject can be a little… dry.

It’s (un)official

“Every vote counts and every vote has not been counted.”

City council to mull recruitment firms

When departing and now former city manager Taylour Tedder was on his way out, he took some steps to try to smooth out the transition to a new city executive in the form of five recruitment firms vying for the call to be hired to conduct a nationwide search for his replacement.

Brown proud to represent BC in Nationals

For those who are into the rodeo scene, you may want to remember the name Aiden Brown in years to come.

Church seeks senior housing

Leaders of the Boulder City United Methodist Church have a project in the works that they feel will benefit many in the community but understand those who may have concerns.

Fancier/foster permit back on city council agenda

If you call in to a city council meeting for public comment twice in one meeting, you officially qualify as a gadfly. (noun: 1) a fly that bites livestock, especially a horsefly, warble fly, or botfly. 2) an annoying person, especially one who provokes others into action by criticism.) Fred Voltz, already quoted in these pages for comments on other issues, also addressed the issue of pet breeding, likening the practice to prostitution or the dealing of narcotics.

Liquor Board approves BC Company Store request

In the 1930s, the original Boulder City Company Store included a “club room.” The city was officially dry until the late 1960s, so booze would not have been officially served. Except it was.