72°F
weather icon Clear

Judge lifts gag order

Updated April 21, 2018 - 7:39 am

The gag order issued by Boulder City Municipal Court Judge Victor Miller against counsel in the crosswalk protest case has been invalidated in Nevada’s Eighth District Court.

On Monday, Judge Susan H. Johnson granted a writ of mandamus to attorney Stephen Stubbs that he filed a petition for March 2 to restore his right to free speech. Stubbs claimed that Miller took away those rights through a gag order he issued in the city’s case against his client, Boulder City resident John Hunt.

Hunt was arrested on several charges after a crosswalk protest against a police-sanctioned pedestrian enforcement event.

In her written order granting the writ, Johnson said that two reasons gag orders are issued are to avoid prejudicing the jury pool and preventing “a carnival atmosphere in a high-profile case.”

In the city’s case against Hunt, Johnson said there is no prejudice to a jury pool because the municipal court does not conduct trials by jury.

“Further, the five misdemeanor charges pending against Mr. Hunt, which consist mostly of traffic violations, could hardly be classified as highly profile or even interesting to Boulder City’s residents,” she wrote. “To put it bluntly, this court concludes Mr. Stubbs has not, and frankly, cannot create a ‘carnival atmosphere’ by making posts about the case and his adversary on his Facebook page.”

She also wrote that Judge Miller’s concern that the post would disrupt the case or prejudice “an adjudicative proceeding” made it appear that he was “more concerned of the prejudice to him in deciding the legal issues.”

She said that Miller’s gag order was too broad and could be violated if the counsel disparaged their adversary in a private conversation at their homes.

“Though my order talks throughout about public speech, because I did not specifically use the word ‘public’ communication in the last sentence of the order, she concluded it was too broad,” Miller said. “I thought it was clear from the context that my order only referred to public comments. I respect our judicial system that provides many layers of review and sometimes, like here, the higher court sees the case differently.”

Miller also said that his gag order was an attempt to get the attorneys to “play nice” and keep the trial in the courtroom and not on social media.

“It was my intent to keep this simple misdemeanor case from having a circus atmosphere,” he said. “The district court order does acknowledge that an attorney’s speech may be regulated. Our legal profession expects attorneys to be professional and act with a certain decorum. That is what my order was attempting to encourage. In fact, the district judge repeats the law that ‘preventing a carnival atmosphere in a high profile case is also a legitimate reason to gag an attorney,’ which seemed to be the direction the case was heading.”

In his petition for the writ, Stubbs said that because City Attorney Steve Morris is Miller’s church leader, Miller may not be able to objectively assess Morris in the courtroom.

In her conclusions of the law in the order, Johnson did not mention anything about their religious relationship.

“I am so grateful that my First Amendment rights were restored in the District Court, and I cannot express to you the joy that I feel in my heart to have my rights back,” Stubbs said. “Judge Miller’s unconstitutional gag order was wrong.”

On April 9, Miller officially recused himself from the Hunt case because a written brief, filed by his attorneys regarding Stubbs’ petition, caused his impartiality to be questioned.

“The underlying issues and the merits of the cases between Mr. Hunt and the city of Boulder City are not implicated or otherwise affected by the recent orders regarding extra judicial communication issued by Judge Miller and by Judge Johnson,” Morris said. “These orders resulted from Mr. Stubbs’ conduct and attacks against city officials, which are irrelevant to the merits of the cases or the issues that will be tried. While efforts to create a “carnival atmosphere” may not be uncommon, the city looks forward to trying the cases in a court of law where facts and relevant evidence are considered and weighed.”

Order granting Writ of Mandamus by Boulder City Review on Scribd

Contact reporter Celia Shortt Goodyear at cgoodyear@bouldercityreview.com or at 702-586-9401. Follow her on Twitter @csgoodyear

THE LATEST
Former fire chief Gray discusses termination

The past few weeks have been a whirlwind for the city, and specifically the fire department, as questions of whether or not Will Gray was still employed as that department’s chief spread through town.

Breeding proposal breeds opposition

Judging by the number of people speaking out against it during public comment at the last city council meeting and the tone of numerous social media posts, the proposal to allow for licensed pet breeders to operate in Boulder City is itself breeding a growing opposition. And the opposition appears to be spilling over into other pet-centric issues, including the fact that, unlike anywhere else in Clark County, Boulder City does not require dogs to be on a leash in public.

Wanted: A good home for theater seats

For those who have either grown up in Boulder City or are longtime residents, the Boulder City Theatre holds a special place in the hearts of many.

Hangars and OHVs and pool people, oh my

In a meeting with only two council members present in the room (and the other three on the phone) and in which the major attention was divided between a contentious possible law concerning pets and the fact that the city manager had announced he was leaving for a new job on the East Coast, the council did take a series of other notable actions.

Look, up in the sky…

Ron Eland/Boulder City Review

Council hears plan for golf course turf reduction

Reducing water usage in Southern Nevada has been a subject that has affected the look of clean, green Boulder City multiple times in the past year.

City confirms fire chief no longer employed

After more than two weeks of inquiries by the Boulder City Review, late Tuesday afternoon the city confirmed that Boulder City Fire Chief Will Gray is no longer employed.

Residents weigh in on 99 Cents Store’s shuttering

In what came as a surprise to many who are frequent shoppers, officials from 99 Cents Only Stores announced last week that all of their 371 locations will be closing over the next several weeks.

Four suspects arrested in graffiti case

On Jan. 22, many residents were shocked by a rash of graffiti throughout town, which included the historic Boulder City Theatre.