92°F
weather icon Clear

Fired city employees file appeal

Two former employees are appealing the dismissal of their complaint accusing the city and council members of violating the open meeting law and breaching a covenant of good faith and fair dealing when they were fired.

In their appeal notice filed Feb. 10 in Nevada Supreme Court, former City Attorney Steve Morris and former City Manager Al Noyola wrote that Nevada’s Eighth District Court “erroneously granted” the motion to dismiss in the Dec. 17 order approved by Judge Jim Crockett.

The dismissal stemmed from complaints filed in August by Morris and Noyola alleging a special meeting scheduled for Aug. 6 to discuss terminating their employment contracts was because they substantiated allegations against Mayor Kiernan McManus, who has been accused by city employees of “religious discrimination, harassment, bullying and creating a hostile work environment.”

They also filed an amended complaint accusing the mayor and City Council of several open meeting law violations. On Nov. 18, Morris and Noyola filed a second amended complaint accusing the city of violating their contracts and state law by not yet paying them their severance packages after they were fired Oct. 13.

Acting City Attorney Brittany Walker said the appeal was “premature.”

“Unless the court certifies the Anti-SLAPP orders dismissing the plaintiffs’ claims as final judgments, they cannot be appealed until all claims in the case have been resolved, including the new claims that plaintiffs included in their second amended complaint,” Walker wrote in an emailed statement. “Regardless, the Anti-SLAPP orders were appropriately entered by the Eighth Judicial District Court Judge, and Boulder City is confident that the rulings will be upheld on appeal.”

The dismissed claims are that the open meeting law was violated with the notice given for the Aug. 6 special meeting; that it was also violated with email communications Aug. 5-6; that it was also violated with a quorum of council members talking to prospective counsel before it was hired by the city; and that an implied covenant of good and fair dealing was breached.

Attorneys for Morris and Noyola did not respond to a request for comment.

In the Dec. 17 order, Crockett dismissed the first two claims because he said “Boulder City met its burden of proof and established by a preponderance of the evidence” that the notice letters, special meeting agenda and email communications were made in good faith in accordance with state statutes.

He also said the emails could be dismissed because they did not constitute a meeting, so they weren’t subject to the open meeting law.

Crockett said that he dismissed the claim of the open meeting law being broken when a quorum of council members talked to prospective counsel before hiring them because council “was forced to seek assistance from outside counsel” as they were sued by the city attorney “who failed to appoint competent substitute counsel to defend the city.”

There are no hearings scheduled yet for this appeal. According to court documents, the court is still waiting for the $250 filing fee to be paid.

In their second amended complaint, Morris and Noyola say their employment contracts were breached because they were fired within six months before a City Council election. Both contracts say they cannot be let go six months before or six months after one.

The next council election is the April 6 primary, less than six months after they were fired.

Bailey Kennedy, the firm representing the city, filed a motion to dismiss parts of that complaint and a hearing is scheduled for 10 a.m. March 11.

On Jan. 4, this case was transferred to Judge Jessica K. Peterson from Crockett, who retired at the start of the year.

Contact reporter Celia Shortt Goodyear at cgoodyear@bouldercityreview.com or at 702-586-9401. Follow her on Twitter @csgoodyear.

MOST READ
THE LATEST
Parallel parking approved

Like so many other things in the world of Boulder City government, the issue of reconfiguring parking in the historic downtown area along Nevada Way, which generated enough heat to cause council members to delay a decision up until the last possible moment, ended with more of a whimper than a bang.

Ways to reduce summer power bills

Now that the thermometer is on the rise outdoors, the cost to cool homes and businesses on the inside is doing the same.

Education news in BC largely positive

In her quarterly report to the city council, Clark County School District Regional Superintendent Deanna Jaskolski was full of positive takes on public schools in Boulder City.

‘It’s in those small moments when you see hope rising’

As Dr. Christina Vela scrolled through her phone, showing photos of girls taking part in various fun activities, for a moment she sounded more like a proud aunt instead of the CEO of St. Jude’s Ranch for Children, and now, its Healing Center.

Jarvis recognized by city council

Salome Jarvis was involved in planning activities for seniors in long-term care before she started doing that in Boulder City. In fact, she helped create the Southern Nevada Activity Professional Association (SNAPA) in the late 1980s.

Park rangers rescue missing hiker, dog at LMNRA

Last week, a 48-year-old male hiker and his dog were rescued by National Park Service rangers at Lake Mead National Recreation Area after a coordinated, multi-agency search.

Fire chief search down to 3

Now that Ned Thomas has had time to unpack a few things in his office and attend a couple of meetings as the new city manager, there’s been a list of things to tackle waiting for him in his new role.

City adopts fiscal year ‘26 budget

It is hands down the most consequential action taken by the city council each year and yet it often happens without much in the way of public comment.

Council reverses planning commission split decision

A permit for building a single home on a lot that has sat empty (though graded and utilities run and ready for development) for some 40 years would not usually be fodder for a news story.