weather icon Mostly Clear

Ethics complaint against mayor dismissed

The Nevada Commission on Ethics recently dismissed a complaint accusing Mayor Kiernan McManus of abusing his position as a public officer because of a “lack of sufficient credible evidence of a violation.”

On March 17, a review panel wrote that the “evidence does not support a factual basis … to demonstrate that McManus used his position as mayor to improperly influence a subordinate,” as claimed in an ethics complaint submitted by former Mayor Roger Tobler and former City Council members Peggy Leavitt, Duncan McCoy and Mike Pacini.

“The decision of the State Ethics Commission is yet another rejection of the deliberate smear campaign that former councilmembers and appointed officials have been waging against me,” McManus wrote in an email to the Boulder City Review. “The allegations made were again found to be baseless and without merit. When I was elected, I promised to have city government work for all of our residents and not a select few. I intend to keep that promise … .”

According to the complaint, McManus bypassed then City Manager Al Noyola and sent a memo to Finance Director Diane Pelletier on Sept. 15 requesting $36,906 in charges be paid to the Bailey Kennedy law firm including $14,400 from before the firm was officially hired by the city. They said by that action he used his position as a public officer to receive legal counsel paid for by the city in a nonofficial capacity.

Leavitt said she was disappointed with the review panel’s decision.

“They did not determine that no ethics violation existed only that there was insufficient evidence to allow them to move forward and render an opinion,” she said. “They let him off on technicalities, such as the fact that he wasn’t sued personally until two weeks after voting to retain Bailey Kennedy as the city’s attorney. Mayor McManus still spent $14,400 in taxpayers’ dollars before that firm was ever retained. … But, regardless, letting somebody off on technicalities doesn’t mean that they didn’t act unethically.”

According to the complaint, McManus also bypassed the city manager’s authority with administrative matters.

“He can’t do that unless it’s through the city manager,” said Tobler. “I’ve been mayor before. I know how it works. You have to follow the rules. … There was a memo. He definitely sent it. It was supposed to go through the city manager.”

According to Boulder City’s charter, City Council “shall deal with the administrative service solely through the City Manager, and neither the Council nor any member thereof shall give orders to subordinates of the City Manager, either publicly or privately.”

The group claims by sending his memo to Pelletier instead of Noyola, who was still employed by the city at the time, McManus violated NRS 281A.400(9) that prohibits him as a public officer from “attempt(ing) to benefit a significant personal or pecuniary interest” of his own “through the influence of any subordinate.”

“After all, the mayor not only has a significant personal interest in the outcome of the litigation in terms of its potential impact on his reputation, presumed competence and character, and political career, but also a significant pecuniary interest since he has been sued individually for attorney’s fees, compensatory damages, and possibly even punitive damages,” they wrote.

Tobler said that as mayor McManus should not change the process outlined in the charter or break the law.

“At the end of the day, I want the city to be successful,” he said.

“I thought there was a problem with a series of those transactions but apparently the commission didn’t think there was enough to worry about,” added McCoy about the determination.

Since this complaint was dismissed, no more proceedings will be held. All the allegations of state law violations are also dismissed.

Memo to Finance Director by Boulder City Review on Scribd

Ethics Complaint FINAL by Boulder City Review on Scribd

Panel Determination by Boulder City Review on Scribd

Contact reporter Celia Shortt Goodyear at cgoodyear@bouldercityreview.com or at 702-586-9401. Follow her on Twitter @csgoodyear.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
‘Tis the season in Boulder City

Boulder City is definitely in the holiday spirit.

$24 mil proposed capital project funding

Twenty-four million dollars. It sounds like a lot of money and, indeed, after the costs of personnel, the costs of capital improvements is the largest item in the Boulder City budget.

City reallocates Regional Transportation funding

Substantial amounts of funding allocated to projects in Boulder City by the Regional Transportation Commission were moved around as part of the consent agenda at the meeting of the city council on Tuesday night.

Ready for the holiday

Photos by Ron Eland/Boulder City Review

Council still mulling STR bill

The contentious issue of short-term rentals in Boulder City took another detour this week as a set of bills introduced previously were pulled from the agenda for the meeting scheduled for Nov. 28.

JFK assassination: 60 years later

It’s one of those moments in time that those who were around can tell you exactly where they were and the thoughts that raced through their head when they heard the news.

Yapp: ‘Nothing more green than restoring’

Boulder City has a large core of historic buildings and homes, many built close to a century ago and, as owners have set out to restore some of these structures, some of the challenges have been unexpected.

Directing public to BC parking

A popular tourist destination seven days a week, Boulder City can get especially crowded on weekends.

Bridging the gap between police, students

When Boulder City police officer Eric Prunty accepted the job of school resource officer, in a way he had to take a step back in time more than 30 years to when he was in school.