weather icon Clear

Who wins when the mob rules?

I have been a planning commissioner for more than 10 years. I am also an employee of RPS Homes. Last week’s planning commission meeting was, to date, the worst display of how the idea of mob mentality rules and how shortsighted the “mob” can be.

During the public comment portion of the agenda, prior to the introduction and acceptance of the agenda, members of this community spoke in opposition to an item up for consideration. That agenda item was the rezoning of the old hospital site on Park Street. The property is currently zoned R1-7; the applicant was requesting R1-5.

Before any discussion of the request, community members assailed it as being, among other things, bad for the community, a drag on the home values in the surrounding neighborhood, a detriment to the quality of life for the neighbors, too noisy, resource robbing of water and utilities, incompatible with the community, an increase on the neighborhood traffic, an increase in parking, and the list of negatives goes on.

All of these issues are valid points; all of which the Planning Commission time and again discusses, evaluates and holds a public hearing about prior to any consideration or action.

Whether this was a viable and acceptable request never will be known because the applicant withdrew the request from the agenda, halting any further discussion.

Unfortunately, what did not get discussed are the following facts. The developer might now, without any further action, develop the property as R1-7 with any size or style of home on the property as long as it conforms to the current zoning. One story, two story, big-box ultra modern, whatever, no continuity, etc. It doesn’t matter because as a community we cannot dictate what a builder does with his property. We only regulate zoning and building height. We cannot control color, content, architectural style, etc.

Furthermore, to add insult to injury, the developer can subdivide that property into four custom lots, again without any further action, and with the possibility of very large custom homes being built by private individuals and not the developer, who are free to do anything they want in any style they choose.

Finally, as a worst-case scenario, the developer just can fence off the property and leave it vacant, which does not benefit the community (lost property tax revenue as one example), which would again have very little oversight by the city.

At a “cookies and cheese” meeting with the surrounding neighbors, the developer told the community there would be only seven or eight homes built; the zoning request was for up to 12 homes. It’s important to underscore up to 12 homes; without a zone change the quantity is unknown.

No plans were submitted, as it is customary to design after the zone change request is approved. The extensive process to design a plan based on zoning is typically not done until the zone change is approved, at which point the tentative map process is started.

During the tentative map process, the public has its second and most impactful opportunity to comment on the proposed development and voice its constructive criticism. The comments of all those concerned would have been addressed.

Unfortunately, now that the item has been withdrawn there will be no discussion.

I am grateful for the opportunity to serve my community. I, as do all members of the Planning Commission, take these matters very seriously. We all have a connection and a great affection for this community, and we all care very deeply for its dedicated citizens. Now that the mob has ruled, however, you’ve got to ask yourself has the mob really won, or did its shortsightedness rule the day once again?

Jim Giannosa has been a resident of Clark County since 1981, a resident of Boulder City since 1998 and has served this community as a Boulder City planning commissioner since 2006. He is currently the planning commission chairman. Giannosa has been actively involved in the commercial and residential real estate development business for more than 40 years.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
Attorney selection not surprising

Is history repeating itself? It certainly seems to be the case.

Series shares impact of fraud

Does everything always come down to how much money will be made? Do we know what truth is? Does truth still matter?

Longtime public servant’s efforts benefited city

In recent election years there have been very vocal attempts to disparage the name and reputation of Bruce Woodbury and his family.

Stand together against tyranny of minority

The nation of Israel, our strongest ally in the Middle East, commemorates Holocaust Day on April 8 this year. It is a grim reminder that over 6 million Jews perished at the hands of Nazi Germany and its confederates. The heroes of the Jewish resistance are also recognized and honored.

Continued vigilance against virus needed

As spring arrives with warmer temperatures, we are also beginning to see the slow return to our normal lives. As health experts have advised, the COVID-19 virus has not been defeated yet and we must continue to be responsible for our actions to protect those around us. But progress is being made.

Vote by process of elimination

As we close in on early voting for the April 6 election for two members of City Council, some thoughts have come to me. I interviewed 11 of the 13 candidates for the positions for my website, BoulderCityPodcast.com, and in cooperation with Boulder City Social. Only Ray Turner declined the invitation and the mysterious Brent Foutz didn’t respond at all.

Research candidates before voting

We have a crucial election for two vacant Boulder City council seats coming up. All of us have been told, “Get out and vote.”

Editorial: Government transparency essential

Spring arrives Saturday and with it will come warmer days and lots of sunshine. It’s something that we’re celebrating.

Society benefits from knowledge

The other day I was reminded of what it was like to be part of a protest surrounded by thousands of others. How did the huge protests happen? There was no internet or Facebook or Google telling people where to gather at what time. No one called me to meet them in Grant Park or on Dearborn Street in downtown Chicago, yet I got there, along with thousands of others.

Time is of the essence

This week has me thinking about time.