73°F
weather icon Clear

VICTOR JOECKS: How Trump could save Nevada education

Updated May 15, 2025 - 9:00 pm

The best hope for improving Nevada’s broken education system is coming from Washington, D.C.

State Senate Majority Leader Nicole Cannizzaro and Gov. Joe Lombardo have proposed competing education bills. Cannizzaro’s Senate Bill 460 is aggressively terrible. One of the headline items, more funding for pre-K, is likely unaffordable, given Nevada’s drop in projected revenue. That’s good because pre-K doesn’t produce lasting learning gains but can increase bad behaviors.

The bill calls for a School District Oversight Board. That sounds imposing, but it would convene only if a district’s board of trustees failed “to comply with any state law.” The board would also have a chance to provide a corrective action plan. The board’s authority is limited to trustees not following state law. That is a whole lot of nothing.

Her bill would treat charter and private schools much more harshly than failing public schools. It would stack the membership of the State Charter School Authority with people likely to despise charter schools. It would give school districts new power to stall or stop new charter schools. It would impose new testing and reporting requirements on private schools that accept Opportunity Scholarship recipients. Those regulations would probably lead many private schools to not participate in the program.

In summary, Cannizzaro wants to shield failing public schools from accountability, while punishing the overwhelmingly successful charter and private schools.

Lombardo’s Assembly Bill 584 is better but has some worrying elements. One strong proposal is a requirement that early elementary teachers receive training in phonics and the science of reading. This approach has helped Mississippi — yes, Mississippiachieve the highest demographically adjusted fourth-grade reading scores in the country.

His bill also attempts to change the incentives in public school districts. State officials could eventually take over the operations of underperforming districts and schools. That would include financial management, governance and setting policies. Further, persistently bad schools could be converted into charter schools or run by state officials.

Also, students who attend a chronically low-performing school would become eligible to attend a private school. They would receive up to 90 percent of their per-pupil funding in an account that could be used for tuition.

Given the number of failing schools in Nevada, this would provide school choice to many students.

One major concern is that the bill would impose significant burdens on private schools that choose to participate. It likely would exclude most religious schools and require private schools to administer state tests. Lombardo’s team needs to amend that language out of the bill.

Sadly, legislative Democrats have long opposed helping students trapped in public schools. But Republicans on Capitol Hill may have a solution. They have included $20 billion for a tuition tax credit program in President Donald Trump’s tax cut bill. It would be like a much bigger Opportunity Scholarship program.

Even if it doesn’t come from Carson City, that is the game-changer Nevada education needs.

Listen to Victor Joecks discuss his columns each Monday at noon with Kevin Wall on AM 670 KMZQ Right Talk. Contact him at vjoecks@reviewjournal.com or 702-383-4698. Follow @victorjoecks on X.

MOST READ
LISTEN TO THE TOP FIVE HERE
THE LATEST
A year of hugs, healing and headway

Nov. 7 will mark a year since the ribbon cutting of the St. Jude’s Ranch for Children Healing Center and shortly after, the opening of the since renamed school, Amy Ayoub Academy of Hope.

Some things are true … until they’re not

I don’t often write in this space about things that have already been in the paper. There are a couple of reasons for that. First, it would often mean writing about “old news.”

No dents on this Denton

Pardon the headline wordplay, but at age 100 (with 101 approaching next month) the celebrated Sara [Katherine Pittard] Denton has lived a life with few dents along the way.

Bursting our bewitched bubble

It’s that dreaded time of year again. Monstrous in magnitude. A mysterious ritual. Strange, scary, sinister, and spooky. Macabre and menacing. Dark and gloomy. Dastardly and disturbing. Gruesome and ghoulish. Frightful. Creepy. Petrifying. Even eerie. A wicked, morbid tradition that haunts our city annually.

Mayor’s Corner: Helmets save lives

Emergency personnel in Clark County estimate they respond to four accidents each day involving bikes, e-bikes, or e-scooters. A few of these accidents have involved fatalities of minors — a grim reminder of the dangers of these devices when not used responsibly. Our goal as city leaders is to prevent tragedies from occurring. Any loss of life has a dramatic impact on families, loved ones, friends, as well as on the entire community.

Cheers to 40 years in the biz

I thought I’d talk a little about the newspaper business on the heels of the Review winning seven statewide awards the other night in Fallon.

AI is here. Just ask your neighbors

“I’ve done 10 albums in the past year,” my across-the-street neighbor, Dietmar, told me Sunday morning as we stood in the street between our two houses catching up. He added that his wife, Sarah, had put out two collections of songs in the same time period, adding, “You know it’s all AI, right?”

Astronaut lands in Nevada, so to speak

I wish to begin by noting that when it comes to politics, I am registered nonpartisan. So when writing about Arizona Sen. Mark Kelly, I’m focusing (well, for the most part), on his role as a retired NASA astronaut, not as a politician.