78°F
weather icon Clear

Silencing boards defies constitutional principles

When you cannot work for the city and you don’t want to run for elected office, what can you do to serve your city government directly? You can serve on a City Council-appointed board or commission. We have 11 such boards in the city with dozens of volunteer members.

Volunteers give up their personal time to offer advice and oversight regarding zoning, historic preservation, the airport, the golf courses, parks and recreation and much more.

Except for the Planning Commission, the boards have only advisory powers, but they serve a larger function: They are the city’s broadest interface to the community.

Citizens and reporters who want to understand city decisions can often get a more open response from board members than from the City Council and management.

That may change if Bill No. 1825 passes. Introduced May 8 by Councilman Warren Harhay on behalf of the city manager and the city clerk, this bill pretends its only purpose is to clean up and standardize the language governing the boards. By all appearances, the real purpose is to shut down and shut up the board activists who are starting make the city leadership feel heat over a rapidly lengthening list of mistakes, improprieties and illegalities.

Without a doubt, some cleanup is needed. When I examined the city code for the purpose of writing an ordinance creating a Boulder City Utilities Commission, I could see it clearly: Each board was created separately from all others, without regard to earlier language. As a result, the language needs streamlining for consistency.

If that were all we got with Bill 1825, it would be great, but it goes farther. It sets standards of conduct for all members and allows the city manager to summarily dismiss any member of any board with notice or appeal, based solely on his whim. What kind of offensive conduct does he wish to seek and destroy? Read Item B under standards of conduct:

“B. Board members will make no announcement of, nor give any information about, any pending matter before the board, or action taken by the board, to the press or other media. Board members shall refer inquiries from the press or other media to the staff liaison.”

This blatant violation of the First Amendment to the Constitution is unenforceable in court, but when the city manager has the absolute power to fire without notice, who gets to go to court? Read Item D:

“D. The city manager may remove any board member appointed by the City Council for a violation of a city administrative policy.”

No doubt a violation could and would be found for anyone who speaks out about City Hall’s myriad improprieties. To add insult to injury, Item A makes a requirement that seems suspiciously like a loyalty oath:

“A. Board members are public appointees subject to the standards and provisions of the city’s advisory board standards of conduct as amended from time to time. Board members shall acknowledge the same within 30 days of appointment by filing a written acknowledgment with the city clerk.”

These deficiencies give the lie to anyone who claims to support transparency in government and then votes for this proposal. Consider questions raised but unanswered:

■ Who gets to write the letter of acknowledgment that board members are required to sign? Will it require them to pledge never to speak to the press or media about the matters before their boards?

■ Who defines “press” and “media”? In today’s social media world, doesn’t just about everyone with a Facebook page or Twitter account qualify? Where is the line drawn? For instance, I have a journalism degree but have never been a working journalist. All my writing is on spec. Am I media? Is Tim O’Callaghan, now a church deacon but former editor of the last Boulder City newspaper, media? Is Nathaniel Gee, who has a blog? Is Boulder City Social media? Most likely yes on all counts, if the city manager found it convenient to proclaim it so.

■ If the city manager runs wild and starts dropping board members right and left, what recourse is there? A complete appeals process would be needed to deal with it. This bill allows for no appeals.

Councilman Harhay assures me that the introduction of the bill is just the beginning, and it is subject to change. If he removed the three items that would destroy the purpose of having our boards — items A, B and D — then he would salvage the bill. Otherwise it is safe to predict that, come election time, the constituents of the boards and commissions will savage those who voted for this wrong-headed attempt to stifle the press and public discussion.

Why did the Founding Fathers create freedom of the press? Exactly for these situations.

Dale Napier is a Boulder City business consultant with a background in urban transportation and development.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
THE LATEST
Smart development key to sustainable future

I commend my friend and colleague Mayor (Kiernan) McManus for his comments in the Boulder City Review on Sept. 1 regarding his focus on conservation to best serve the residents of Boulder City. Together, our cities have a long-standing commitment to conservation and sustainability.

Solutions to nation’s woes just take action

What if you had solutions to a multitude of problems? Would you share what you knew or would you hesitate because the facts were contrary to the status quo?

Terrorists killed more than people

Sept. 11 changed us. And not necessarily for the better.

Dont let city become ‘Pothole Paradise’

Two years ago at a public event, a friend got in my face and in an uncharacteristic, agitated voice said, “Fix my street!” Initially I thought he was joking. But after two attempts to change the subject, I realized he wasn’t laughing.

Court of public opinion too quick to judge

Most people know me for my former Throwback Thursday columns with the Boulder City Review and some people may know of me from my failed run for City Council. What people don’t know, however, is that I used to work for actor Johnny Depp through a contract I had running events at multiple properties on the Las Vegas Strip. I was Mr. Depp’s private dining planner for all of his Las Vegas trips, including events with his family.

Relax, it’s Labor Day

Monday is Labor Day, and it’s somewhat ironic that a day devoted to celebrating the American workforce is a day that most of us strive to do anything but work.

Options for conservation must be explored

Fall weather will be a welcome change in the next few weeks, it has been a hot summer. Some of the hottest temperatures on record for Southern Nevada. And most of those records have been over the past few years. We can look at the changes in water levels at Lake Mead and know that things are very different from any other time in our lifetimes.

Agostini, Eagles Closet help those in need

Since the new school year began at the beginning of the month, students and staff members at Boulder City High School have made a variety of changes to help ensure their health and welfare in the wake of COVID-19.

Water’s low cost makes it expendable

Water is essential to life. Humans and every living species can go without many things but not without water; yet many take water for granted. We water our lawns, fill our swimming pools, wash our cars, take long showers, hose down our driveways and rarely even think about the costs involved. Why? Because water is too convenient and, most importantly, inexpensive.

City long devoted to conservation, environmental issues

The water level at Lake Mead fell to 1,068 feet in July 2021. That is the lowest level since the lake was first filled following the Hoover Dam’s dedication in 1935. This month, the federal government has declared a water shortage on the Colorado River for the first time, triggering cutbacks in water allocations to surrounding states from the river.