57°F
weather icon Clear

Keeping campaign promises could be disastrous

Last week 20 Washoe County residents filed a new political party for the state — the Nevada Constitution Party.

Las Vegas Review-Journal capitol reporter Ed Vogel wrote, “Otilia Krapff, the executive director of the new party, said every state but Nevada already has a Constitution Party and she and the others want governments to downsize, taxes to be lowered, term-limits placed on federal elected officials and ‘people elected who say what they are going to do and stick with it.’ ”

Actually, Nevada does already have a Constitution Party. It’s just not called that. Nevada’s Independent American Party, which was formed as a vehicle for George Wallace’s 1968 presidential candidacy, is the Nevada affiliate of the Constitution Party. Last year, the IAP’s line on the Nevada ballot was given over to CP presidential nominee Virgil Goode, the IAP hosted Nevada appearances of Goode, and the IAP’s Janine Hansen is the Western states chairwoman of the Constitution Party.

But that wasn’t the part that really caught my eye in Vogel’s story. It was the quote from Krapff that political candidates should “say what they are going to do and stick with it.”

Why is that a good idea?

Imagine that a candidate ran for the House in the 1938 election on a campaign of “no new taxes.” Starting in 1940, the Congress started enacting the largest tax increases in U.S. history, first to pay for military preparedness and then, after 1941, for war against Japan and Germany. Should that candidate have stuck with his anti-tax position?

In 1928 Herbert Hoover was elected president as a laissez faire candidate who would continue President Calvin Coolidge’s hands-off attitude toward the business community. When that unregulated business community caused the massive financial collapse that caused the Great Depression, Hoover was as good as his word. For three years after the stock market crash, Hoover kept his campaign promise, refusing to use federal power to revive the economy. His commitment to small government and laissez faire economics prevented him from doing anything substantive, and his belief that the business community would right itself and the nation caused the Depression to stretch out for the rest of his term and become almost a semi-permanent institution. And when Hoover did act, he sometimes made things worse, prolonging the Depression, as when he pitted the U.S. against the world’s businesspeople by signing a high tariff law.

It was tragic for those who lived in misery and even died of disease or malnutrition that Hoover could not change his position.

In Nevada in 1950, Republican Charles Russell was elected governor on a pledge not to raise taxes. He had failed to anticipate what effect that pledge would have on the state’s parents and children in the entirely foreseeable postwar frenzy. The troops had come home from World War II mostly in 1946. It was during Russell’s governorship that the baby boom started being felt in state and local programs and agencies and, above all, in the schools.

The Nevada birthrate jumped 57 percent in the first five months of 1947 over the same period of 1946. The state’s school system neared collapse. A state that always had low taxes suddenly could not pay for desperately needed school construction and the cost of educating the largest classes in history.

Parents organized to demand higher taxes, but Russell decided to stick with his campaign pledge. Nevadans lost four long years because it was held hostage to his promise. In 1954 he was re-elected without a no-taxes pledge and the state was finally able to pay for an adequate (although not more) school system. Until then, baby boomers had suffered through inferior early educations.

The first George Bush is often faulted for breaking his 1988 “no new taxes” pledge. But imagine the economic consequences if he had not. During the Reagan decade the nation had lived on hot checks and its economy was being damaged by the consequences of deficit spending. The deficit had more than tripled in 10 years and was a drag on the economy.

Franklin Roosevelt, who replaced Hoover as president, once said that he believed he should “take a method and try it. If it fails, admit it frankly and try another. But above all, try something.”

Keeping every campaign promise would have a nice abstract, ivory tower symmetry, but in the real world it would be a disaster. Those like the Constitution Party organizers want candidate allegiance to dogma, not candidates who learn from experience.

Dennis Myers is a veteran and Nevada journalist.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
THE LATEST
Power of people remains at polls

This Sunday is the first anniversary of the Women’s March. Don’t fret, I’m not writing a commercial. I’m looking at a very abbreviated history of individuals coming together to make a statement.

Potential for adventure in city gets real

Reality TV and Boulder City are starting to become a common thing. Recently, the HGTV show “Flip or Flop Vegas” filmed in our quaint town, with an episode promised to air this upcoming summer. However, the likes of Tommy Lee (Mötley Crüe) and Gear Duran aka Gear Boxxx (“Skin Wars”) have had Boulder City ties for sometime now.

Finding right school for child’s needs key to success

Later this month, schools, homeschool groups, organizations and individuals in Nevada and across America will work together to raise awareness about the importance of opportunity in K-12 education.

Mayor should consider re-election

Who will run for mayor in 2019? I realize that we are over a year away from people even putting their names in the hat. Yet, if they are serious about running, they need to start thinking now.

Awards for revitalization efforts, faith in city well-deserved

At our final 2017 City Council meeting, I had the privilege of presenting two Mayor’s Awards, one to All Mountain Cyclery and the other to The Tap, for their 2017 business corridor revitalization efforts. These two businesses weren’t the only ones that worked to spruce up our commercial sector, but the scale of their projects and their commitment to reinvest in our community really stood out to me.

Eastwood accepts ‘Gauntlet,’ runs with it

Actor, producer and writer Clint Eastwood came through Boulder City for a 1977 film titled “The Gauntlet.” While Eastwood was always on board to direct the Warner Bros. picture, he wasn’t the first or second choice to star in the film.

Though popular, bitcoin not wave of future

Bitcoin. It’s everywhere. You see it in the news. People talk about it around the water cooler, and it appears on almost every internet ad. I wouldn’t be surprised if it started appearing in local paper opinion pieces.

Veteran uses talents to help other veterans

Robert Serge served in the United States Navy for 20 months as part of an ordnance laboratory test facility. As he puts it, “We designed harbor mines and stuff like that.”

Smiles plant seeds of hope

Before I sit down to write any commentary, I spend lots of time daily thinking about how to begin. What happened today? What needs addressing? I take so many things so seriously, I end up changing the focus daily. As soon as I submit one commentary, I begin thinking about the next. This one took longer than usual.