82°F
weather icon Clear

City’s outside legal expenses require monitoring

Boulder City pays City Attorney Brittany Walker an annual salary of $125,000, plus extensive insurance coverage, PERS contributions, paid leave and other benefits. But the city also pays hundreds of thousands of dollars each year to outside attorneys. For instance, in fiscal year 2020-21, the amount paid to outside legal counsel was almost $700,000, pushing the city’s annual legal expenses that year close to $1 million.

The city attorney generally engages outside attorneys to assist with her duties, to defend lawsuits against the city not covered by insurance, and for more specialized areas of practice like labor law, utilities, ethics law and criminal matters.

The following is a summary of how the city has used outside attorneys over the last 2 ½ years.

The City Council’s October 2020 firing of former City Manager Al Noyola and former City Attorney Steve Morris has turned into a very expensive legal battle. Morris and Noyola filed the lawsuit alleging various wrongful termination claims, including numerous violations of Nevada’s open meeting law, breaches of contract, retaliatory discharge, bad faith and civil conspiracy, among others. Refusing to pay severance to Noyola and Morris, the mayor and certain City Council members instead elected to fight back, forcing the city to pay over $300,000 in legal fees to the law firm Bailey Kennedy over the last year and a half.

The suit is currently on appeal with no foreseeable end in sight. So, we can expect the city to continue accruing legal fees in this matter at the rate of almost $20,000 per month for years to come. For instance, the city’s attorneys recently filed an 80-page appeal brief, which will likely cost us another $50,000 or more in fees.

At some point, one has to question whether that $350,000 (escalating rapidly toward a half million or more) would have been better spent buying out Morris and Noyola’s contracts, especially since the city may end up having to pay them over a million dollars in severance anyway.

The foregoing amounts don’t even include almost $18,000 in legal fees spent on a related investigation into several complaints filed by city employees against Mayor (Kiernan) McManus based on harassment, bullying, hostile work environment and discrimination.

Furthermore, in addition to Bailey Kennedy, two other law firms represent the city and the mayor in the lawsuit. And although the city’s insurance pool is now footing the bill for the tens of thousands more being paid to those firms, it appears the city had to pay handsome deductibles to initially retain them.

The city has categorized all of its legal fees spent on the Noyola/Morris litigation and on employee complaints against the mayor as “risk management” funds. And knowing that these matters will likely drag on for several more years, the mayor has been pushing hard to increase the size of that risk management fund. But maybe it’s time the City Council engages in some real risk management analysis to figure out a way to stop the bleeding before these claims balloon so far out of control that they’re beyond the point of no return?

Over the last 2 ½ years, the city has also spent almost $500,000 in outside legal fees on airport matters, including three lawsuits filed against the city and the city’s own internal assessment of airport hangar issues. One of the lawsuits was filed by Bob Fahnestock and his company BFE LLC against the city for taking over the airport’s fuel farm and allegedly refusing to permit him to dispense fuel from a mobile tender.

The other two lawsuits, filed by airport hangar owners Rob Martin and others, involve their refusal to acknowledge the city’s asserted right to take over ownership of the hangars upon expiration of long-standing hangar leases.

Over a quarter of a million dollars in outside legal fees was spent on airport-related matters in fiscal year 2020-21 alone.

Legal expenses paid by the city’s general fund, which total almost $400,000 over the last 2 ½ years, make up the lion’s share of remaining legal fees spent on outside attorneys. Those include approximately $72,000 expended over that same period on labor and employment-related matters. They also include $60,000 paid yearly to Gary Booker for his assistance with criminal matters, plus another $20,000 paid to provide assistance during Brittany Walker’s leaves of absence and on real estate and contract-related matters.

All told, the city has spent an average of almost a half-million dollars annually on outside attorneys over the last 2 ½ years, which equates to a little over $40,000 each month.

One can certainly debate whether or not that was money well spent. But it seems extremely high for a small town that prides itself on fiscal responsibility and traditionally pinches pennies when it comes to hiring its own salaried employees.

Things like the $687,000 settlement that the city recently paid to Tab Contractors Inc., an item that was buried last month in a consent agenda item and approved without any real opportunity for public discussion, also raise serious questions about transparency when it comes to the city’s legal expenses.

Sometimes it seems like the message being sent is shame on us for not paying closer attention. Hopefully we’ll wake up and ask the right questions before big legal expenses like these overwhelm us.

The opinions expressed above belong solely to the author and do not represent the views of the Boulder City Review. They have been edited solely for grammar, spelling and style, and have not been checked for accuracy of the viewpoints.

Rod Woodbury has resided in Boulder City for more than 40 years and is the president and managing shareholder of his law firm, Woodbury Law. He served on the City Council from 2011- 2019, including four years as mayor.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
THE LATEST
Electric vehicles not really friendly to environment

As somewhat of a gearhead, I am fascinated with the newest technologies relating to electric-powered vehicles, otherwise known as EVs. Tesla is thought to be the leader in these technologies. Still, others, such as Hyundai, Honda, Toyota and Kia, along with the major car manufacturers in the USA, have been making significant strides in developing electric vehicles with outstanding performance.

Pictures of past tell many stories

I know this is an opinion column and what I’ve written here is less of an opinion piece and more of an amusing anecdote. I hope you’ll forgive me for that. It was simply too good not to share and I think it’s a nice, if mundane, example of why Boulder City is such a lovely place to live.

Water conservation efforts to thwart drought delusional

I was entering my junior year at Boulder City High School when Lake Mead reached its top elevation of 1,225 feet in 1983. Water rushed over Hoover Dam’s fully extended spillway gates with such force that even an umbrella didn’t keep us dry from the downpour caused by its rebounding spray. Since then, the lake has dropped 185 feet, including a 170-foot decline over the last 22 years during the worst Colorado River system drought in recorded history.

Guest commentary: Are fair elections possible in digital age?

I am wondering whether or not we should be paying attention to how our elections are being conducted in Nevada as to whether or not our votes are actually counted fairly. I suspect that the voting machines have a lot to do with the situation.

A retreat to push us forward

Succeeding in today’s business climate is not an easy task. It’s even more challenging for women, who have had to overcome decades of inequality in the workplace while juggling traditional roles of keeper of the home and family.

Keep ‘wet blankets’ out of water talks

“Blanket statements” are usually meant to cover wide swaths of a topic. A “wet blanket,” on the other hand, implies stifling everything it touches or, in this context, greatly limiting a topic’s discussion. If this column comes somewhere between one or the other, I’ll consider it a success.

Reparations needed from president’s supporters

What exactly are reparations? The Merriam-Webster definition is: “The act of making amends, offering expiation or giving satisfaction for a wrong, injury, or something done or given as amends.”

Human presence essential for meaningful conversation

For those I speak to in person, I am better able to receive kindness, love and meaning. The consciousness of the soul is available from our hearts. For those who are willing to continue to communicate in person, there can continue to be love flowing from the hearts of each person in any conversation.

Balance between work, school volunteering tough to find

Back-to-school is one of my favorite times of the year. I loved school supply shopping as a kid and now, as a parent, I love taking my kids shopping for their school supplies. Watching my daughter choose from the colorful folders with her supply list in hand is too adorable for words. I genuinely enjoy attending the back-to-school nights, meeting my children’s teachers and learning about their curriculum for the year. But guilt often overshadows that excitement when the teachers try to rope parents into joining the parent-teacher organization.