107°F
weather icon Clear

Frustration grows as group aims to preserve historic properties

Members of the Boulder City Historic Preservation Committee grew increasingly frustrated at a meeting Wednesday night as the group continues work to create a historic preservation code with teeth.

Committee members have been unable to find common ground with Planning Commission members, who feel that code amendments proposed by the preservation committee are too regulatory.

“It seems to me like the Planning Commission doesn’t want to change our code,” committee member Linda Graham said. “I just feel like every suggestion we made has been shot down.”

The committee is hoping to model its new preservation code off the state of Connecticut’s code, which gives stronger regulatory power to protect historic architecture.

According to preservation committee member Kiernan McManus, who proposed the new code, some members of the Planning Commission fear that any plan that tells people what to do on privately owned property could put the city at risk of litigation. Other Planning Commission members are open to a change in the preservation code.

“The Planning Commission is not unified in this. Some people like Mr. Matuska and Mr. McDonald have been very open to working with us, but Mr. Leavitt does not believe any of this should be done,” said McManus said, referring to commission members Paul Matuska, Fritz McDonald and Glen Leavitt.

During the Sept. 28 preservation committee meeting, McDonald said he would support the new preservation code as long as the city attorney signs off on it.

In a recent legal opinion, City Attorney Dave Olsen said language in the new preservation code would be too ambiguous, citing the Nevada Supreme Court case Gallagher v. Las Vegas, which concluded that retired firefighters were eligible for benefits after suffering from heart disease because of their jobs. The court stated that because of the language and history of the city’s statute, the firefighters deserved the benefits.

Olsen’s opinion stated that an ambiguous code could put the city at risk for a lawsuit.

However, preservation committee member Alan Goya said enforced regulations were the point because that is how to protect historical areas. “The new code is supposed to give greater guidelines and regulations; that is the whole point,” he said.

Goya then stated that the proposed code amendments were on par with other areas’ preservation codes.

“This is not different than anything else that is proposed,” Goya said. “Why does this code work everywhere else but not here.”

City Planner Susan Danielewicz recommended the committee focus on changing the little things with the ultimate goal of slowly molding the code until it gets what it wants.

“Things happen in baby steps in Boulder City, so you should go for the low-hanging fruit,” Danielewicz said. “Drafting up amendments can help you be more authoritative.”

The committee agreed it would continue to work on the language to help appease the Planning Commission and work on drafting small changes to the code over time.

City Council members have said they support the committee’s efforts to create a more comprehensive preservation code, but they did not feel comfortable approving new amendments without the blessing of the Planning Commission.

Contact reporter Max Lancaster at mlancaster@bouldercityreview.com or at 702-586-9401. Follow him on Twitter @MLancasterBCR.

MOST READ
LISTEN TO THE TOP FIVE HERE
THE LATEST
Council confusion: The leash law saga continues

Three statements — notably, none of them from members of the city council — best illustrated the difficulties residents (both dog-loving and not) have had for at least four years when it comes to the issue of off-leash dogs in public parks.

Breeding in BC? Probably not

Unlike the discussion later in the meeting Tuesday night in which the city council appeared determined to make sure no one was angry at them about the issue of off-leash dogs, they directed staff to take very strong action on the issue of pet breeding.

Lifejacket donations aim to save lives

Greg Bell’s memory lives on by way of a generous donation that may saves lives.

Huge crowd turns out to honor Patton

It was brought up during Saturday’s unveiling of the Shane Patton Memorial Monument as to why Shane’s statue stands 11 feet tall.

Disaster in China affects Damboree fireworks show

As the city prepares for Damboree, one of our biggest celebrations of the year, a tragedy in China is having an impact on the annual fireworks show.

City Celebrates First Responders

Photos courtesy City of Boulder City

Toll Brothers gets split decision

The development of the area near Boulder Creek Golf Course known as Tract 350 (the sale of which is slated to pay for the majority of the planned replacement for the aging municipal pool) may have hit a snag last week as the planning commission voted 5-1 to deny the developers’ request to build houses closer to the street than is allowed under current law.